Skip to content
Compare

ChurchFoundry vs Tithely: a church software checklist

Comparing ChurchFoundry and Tithely? If giving comes first for you, here’s what to test in both, from refunds and statements to who can see what.

30 days free · No credit card · No sales call

What Tithely offers

Tithely’s church management page covers a people database with tags, groups that people join through its church app, service planning (its song library and SongSelect integration need an upgrade), forms linked to member profiles, automations, kids check-in with security codes, events with room booking and volunteer scheduling, text and email, a giving dashboard and MinistrySafe background checks. The page lists prices for each package, with processing fees separate, and answers common questions.

If you’re looking at Tithely, compare the exact package you’d need, how giving connects to your people records and how volunteers work with service plans.

What to look at in ChurchFoundry

Tithely sells giving on its own as well as inside its church management packages, so put giving first in your test. ChurchFoundry charges gifts on your church’s own Stripe account and takes no cut; Stripe’s fees are between your church and Stripe. Gifts can be one-time or recurring, donors can choose to cover the fee, refunds go back through Stripe in full or in part, and statements come out as PDFs for one donor or the whole year.

Then look at what sits around each gift. In ChurchFoundry, gifts post to fund accounting on their own, the Treasurer role covers giving and the books and nothing else, and pastors see giving totals without seeing who gave. Service planning includes the song library and volunteer requests.

Compare the same scope and cost

Tithely’s page lists a price for each package, with processing fees shown separately. Put the package you’d need beside the ChurchFoundry plan that covers the same work, and compare the processing you’d actually pay on your giving: ChurchFoundry adds nothing on top of Stripe’s fees. We don’t copy other companies’ prices here, and we don’t mark a feature as missing just because we couldn’t confirm it.

ChurchFoundry imports Tithe.ly exports: your transactions, and your people if you have that export too. The preview shows donor matches, dates, funds and totals before anything is saved. Recurring gifts don’t move with the history, so plan how donors will set them up again.

Use the trials to answer the practical questions

In both trials, give a test gift online, refund part of it, record a cash gift and run a year-end statement for one donor. Then sign in as your treasurer and as your pastor and check what each of them sees.

This is a vendor-written evaluation guide: we make ChurchFoundry, so weigh it that way. Tithely is another company’s product, and we’re not affiliated with it. We read the official page linked below on October 30, 2026.

Official sources

Products and prices change, so check each provider's current information too.

By Moriah LLC, makers of ChurchFoundry · Reviewed

Questions

Common questions

Is this an independent ranking of Tithely and ChurchFoundry?

No. We make ChurchFoundry and wrote this checklist from Tithely’s official pages. Try both with your own jobs and check current prices before you decide.

Can we bring our Tithe.ly giving history across?

Yes. Upload your Tithe.ly transaction export, and your people export if you have one. The preview shows donor matches, funds and totals before anything is saved.

Keep reading

Related reading

How to choose church management software

Don’t choose church management software from a feature list. Choose it by trying the three jobs that eat your week, with the people who actually do them.

ChurchFoundry vs Breeze

Breeze is now Tithely Church Management. If its one flat price is what you like, here’s what to test against a plan priced by your church’s size.

Plans & pricing

Published plan prices, a Free plan, and 30 days to try every feature.

Your next guest could be followed up this Sunday.

Set up your church, invite your team and see how it fits before you pay anything.

30 days free. No credit card. Cancel any time.